I realize the boating season is winding down but I am curious what style anchors and and anchor systems people are using out there. I am looking for an anchor that i can count on to set and hold a 21 ft boat in 2-4 ft waves in various bottom types. Right now I am using a digger achor with 150 ft rope and this does work pretty decent( probally 75% of the time) but need something when this fails to work. thanks.
I use the Bruce anchor (D), originally developed for offshore oil and gas drilling rigs, is an excellent burying type of anchor. It gives a good performance approximation of a cross between the Danforth and a Mushroom anchor. It holds well in sandy bottoms and mud. Plus it hooks rocks good.
7/16 5/8 240 46-50 30,000 1/2 11/16 315 51-60 50,000 9/16 3/4 360 *Danforth is a registered trademark. Similar-style anchors may differ
significantly in performance.
**S indicates standard anchor; B indicates high-tensile anchor
This chart was found in the SAIL 1997 Sailboat Buyers Guide. Their Web Address is: www.sailbuyersguide.com
To obtain maximum holding power of your anchor, the total anchor rode should be 4 to 7 times the depth of the water you will be anchoring in.
A good compromise between all-nylon or all-chain rode is a short length of chain (6'-30') connected to the anchor, with a long length of three-strand nylon line connected to the chain. This combination satisfies nearly all requirements of a good anchor rode, except that it is not abrasion resistant over its entire length. Long scope must be used to keep the pull on the anchor shank horizontal. Nylon is preferred for its elasticity. Its stretch reduces peak loads on the anchor and on your boat. The primary function of chain is to handle the chafe from rough bottoms that would otherwise abrade the soft nylon line.
Scope is defined as the ratio of water depth (plus freeboard) to anchor line paid out. Most anchoring texts and anchor manufacturers agree that a scope of 7:1 achieves the anchor's designed holding power, and more scope is better than less. In theory, 7:1 scope is great, but at a crowded anchorage most cruisers scoff at the idea of paying out more than 3:1 or 4:1-there just isn't much space for boats to swing. Any reduction in scope, of course, must be made up for by using larger anchors and/or larger chain.
How much chain you should have in a chain-and-rope anchor rode is not fixed because of the variety of factors involved (boat displacement, draft, surface conditions, etc.). There isn't a set formula for equating the amount of line to chain in an anchor rode. John Rousmaniere, the noted author of "The Annapolis Book of Seamanship," recommends at least six to 10 feet of chain accompany every anchor rode (except of course those for dinghies and those that are all-chain), but that's a bare minimum for anything over 25 feet LOA. You could say that twice as much line as chain would keep you safe in almost any situation.
Calculations for the optimum length of chain on a combined nylon chain rode are complex. However William van Dorn in "Oceanography and Seamanship"; Dodd, Mead (1974), presents a graph based on calculations for anchoring oceanographic vessels in storm conditions. It suggests that the optimum chain/nylon combination for anchoring vessels < 50ft. in 30 ft. of water under storm conditions is a 20% chain, 80% nylon rode with an overall scope of 6:1. Assuming that the boat's bow chock is 6 feet above the water and that the waves are 4 feet (8 feet peak to trough) this works out to a 240 foot total rode comprised of 48 feet of chain and 192 feet of nylon. Clearly these are extreme conditions. In shallower water the rode could be reduced proportionately. However, the length of chain required approximates one boat length and a good working rule for a combined rode is a boat length of chain plus whatever nylon is required to give a 6:1 scope. In shallower water, the scope should be increased, within swing limitations, to 7:1 to permit the bow to lift more easily to the choppy waves near the shore.
In summary, at a fixed anchoring depth, the longer the rode, the less chain required. The shortest rodes are achieved with all chain, the heavier the better, but the penalty is increased weight and handling difficulty, and the slightly increased possibility of catastrophic failure if the chain stretches taut.